Before I started as a Stylist for Color Street, my stylist friends would all talk about how much they loved Mineral Fusion Nail Polish Remover. I have always just used whatever generic brand polish remover was out there, so spending ~$11 on a bottle of nail polish remover seemed like a lot! On the other hand, I know several people who use it, and don’t have a lot of damage to their nails like I used to experience.
After watching my nails get more brittle with time when I used generic polish remover, I decided to try a couple different ones. Here’s how they all compared.
- Up & Up Acetone Free Polish Remover from Target
The generic acetone free nail polish remover I used to use was ok. Using the technique that I talked about in a previous post, where I put polish remover on a cotton ball, and used nail clips to hold it on my nail, each nail had to soak for about 5 minutes minimum. Once I removed the the clip, especially if I was wearing glitters, I’d sometimes still have to wipe my nail with a clean cotton ball (with fresh polish remover on it). I sometimes could use a different part of the same cotton ball. It was effective, but took a while, especially since I only did one hand at a time. My finger tips often felt a bit dry afterwards.
- After double checking what I had in my cabinet, the most recent bottle I used was actually NOT acetone free! I must have grabbed the wrong one at the store. I really had been trying to stick with acetone free. haha The results were very similar. The acetone remover may have worked a bit quicker than acetone free, I don’t really remember, because it’s been a long time since I’ve used it.
2. Mineral Fusion Nail Polish Remover
Mineral Fusion is an acetone free nail polish remover. It doesn’t smell as bad (or as strong) as most other polish removers. It is gentle on nails, and your skin. It doesn’t dry them out, or leave any kind of residue. I have used Mineral Fusion with cotton balls with clips, and in the baggie trick (see previous post referenced above). It works faster than the Up & Up brand, and can be used often, without damage to your nails.
3. Olive & June Acetone Free Dip-style Nail Polish Remover
I saw a video of another stylist using the jar style polish remover, and it worked really fast. In the video, she used one that was from Target. I wanted to try it, but two different Targets were out of their brand on several different attempts to find it. I thought I would try the Olive & June brand. It was very small, and cost about $11. I was hopeful that it would work quickly to remove my manicure.
The insert was a foam sponge. It started breaking apart almost as soon as I start twisting my finger in it to remove the polish. I kept getting little chunks of foam, and it was smudging the polish, leaving a weird residue on my finger nails. I tried it on two different occasions, and did not like it at all. I actually threw the tub out. I definitely would not buy this again.
4. Up & Up 100% acetone nail polish remover dip-it
I searched everywhere for this magical little jar, and finally got lucky! In the video I had seen, the Stylist said she dumped out the polish remover that was in it, and poured Mineral Fusion in. Since I knew I was going to be writing a post comparing polish removers, I thought I’d try it with the existing remover first.
When I opened it, I was impressed to find that it was not a sponge or foam inside, as I had expected, but was a plastic bristle style brush inside. That explains how she could just dump out the existing polish, and put in her preferred brand without cross contamination in the sponge. Note: it is REALLY full, and spills easily! Have something handy to wipe up spills when you open it.
The jar says it “removes glitter and gel polish from natural nails” and “removes artificial nails”. It is 100% acetone, so it’s going to be stronger. It definitely smelled like nail polish remover! Blech! That said, OMG, did it work amazingly well! It was quick and easy. The polish came off, and no residue! My hand and nails did feel more dry than when I use Mineral Fusion, but the result was equivalent.
In the end, out of the several I compared, I still choose Mineral Fusion. I really liked the jar technique, especially with the plastic bristles. I am going to reuse the Target dip it jar for sure, but will replace the remover inside.
I’d love to hear your thoughts on nail polish removers you’ve tried!